Collagen-Rich Foods vs. Supplements: Which is Right for You?

Collagen-Rich Foods vs. Supplements: Which is Right for You?

Incorporating collagen into your diet can support healthy skin, joint function, and muscle recovery, but how you get your collagen matters. Natural sources of collagen, like bone broth and fish, have long been used to support wellness. However, collagen supplements are specifically designed to deliver a concentrated dose of this essential protein. So, which option is better for specific health goals? In this article, we’ll look at the benefits of food-based collagen versus supplements, and help you decide which might be the right choice for your wellness routine.

Understanding Collagen: Why Do We Need It?

Collagen is the body’s most abundant protein, forming the structural support for skin, joints, bones, and muscles. As we age, collagen production declines, leading to wrinkles, joint discomfort, and decreased muscle resilience. Supplementing with collagen—whether through food or supplements—can help maintain collagen levels and support skin elasticity, joint health, and muscle strength.

Collagen-Rich Foods: Benefits and Limitations

Natural Sources of Collagen

Food-based sources of collagen include bone broth, chicken skin, fish, and eggs. These options are rich in collagen and provide additional nutrients, like minerals and amino acids, which support bone and joint health.

To see our article on how to get collagen on a plant-based diet click here.

Benefits of Collagen-Rich Foods

  • Nutrient Density: Whole foods contain additional vitamins and minerals that aid in absorption and overall health.
  • Easily Incorporated into Meals: Bone broth or fish can be added to everyday meals, making it simple to include collagen naturally.
  • Other proteins: while collagen may be the most prevalent protein in our body, we do need others for our body to adapt and repair.

Limitations

  • Lower Concentration: Collagen in food sources is less concentrated than supplements, which means you may need to consume large amounts to achieve similar benefits.
  • Preparation Time: Collagen-rich foods like bone broth require significant time to prepare, which may not be feasible for a busy lifestyle.

Collagen Supplements: Concentrated and Convenient

Types of Collagen Supplements

The best collagen supplements are hydrolysed, meaning they’re broken down into smaller, absorbable peptides. This makes them more easily absorbed by the body and allows for targeted benefits. 

Benefits of Collagen Supplements

  • Higher Concentration: Collagen supplements provide a concentrated dose, which can be more effective for skin, joint, and muscle health.
  • Enhanced Absorption: Hydrolysed collagen in supplements is more bioavailable, allowing for faster and more efficient absorption.
  • Convenience: With options like Mango, Orange, and Blackcurrant flavours, Benjamin Button collagen is easy to take daily, fitting seamlessly into a busy routine.

Limitations

  • Additional Cost: Collagen supplements can be more expensive than natural sources, although they offer higher potency and convenience.
  • Single Nutrient Focus: Unlike collagen-rich foods, supplements do not provide the additional vitamins and minerals that come with whole foods.

Which Option is Right for You?

For Skin and Anti-Ageing

If your primary goal is improving skin elasticity and reducing wrinkles, collagen supplements may be more effective due to their concentration and bioavailability. Benjamin Button’s liquid collagen, enhanced with sodium hyaluronate and vitamin C, is ideal for maximising skin hydration and firmness.

For Joint Health and Physical Activity

Those focused on joint health and physical recovery may benefit from both dietary collagen and supplements. Whole foods like bone broth provide valuable nutrients for joint lubrication, while collagen supplements offer a concentrated boost for joint support.

For Daily Wellness and Balanced Diets

If you’re looking for overall wellness and enjoy a natural diet, incorporating collagen-rich foods like fish and eggs can be beneficial. For added ease and targeted effects, supplements make a valuable addition to support both beauty and health goals.

FAQs About Collagen

Q: Can I combine collagen-rich foods with supplements?
A: Yes, combining collagen foods and supplements can provide a comprehensive approach, supporting collagen levels from both dietary and supplementary sources.

Q: How long does it take for collagen to show results?
A: Results vary, but most people experience benefits for skin elasticity and joint comfort within 8 to 12 weeks of consistent use.

Q: Is Benjamin Button a good brand for collagen supplements?
A: Absolutely! Benjamin Button provides high-quality, hydrolysed collagen with added vitamin C and sodium hyaluronate, designed for skin, joint, and muscle health. 

Q: Which is more effective: collagen supplements or foods?
A: Collagen supplements are more concentrated and bioavailable, offering faster results, while collagen-rich foods provide additional nutrients beneficial for overall health.

Q: Can collagen help with joint discomfort?
A: Yes, collagen helps support joint cartilage and reduces inflammation, which can ease joint discomfort and improve flexibility.

Summary

Both collagen-rich foods and supplements offer unique benefits. Food sources provide a holistic approach, including additional nutrients, while supplements offer a concentrated, convenient boost for those seeking specific health results. Benjamin Button provides high-quality liquid collagen options designed for optimal absorption, making it easy to incorporate collagen into any lifestyle.

Conclusion

Choosing between collagen-rich foods and supplements depends on your health goals and lifestyle. For a natural approach to wellness, dietary collagen sources like bone broth and fish can be beneficial. However, if you’re seeking targeted results for skin elasticity, joint flexibility, or muscle recovery, collagen supplements like those offered by Benjamin Button provide a practical, potent solution. Adding collagen to your daily routine—through food, supplements, or a blend of both—can support a radiant, active life at any age.

Back to blog